journey of doing »

Christmas Sugar Cookies – Cookie Cutter Friendly!

Today would have been my dad’s birthday, which always brings up all kinds of fantastic childhood memories of celebrations and holidays.  (My family did holidays really well when I was a child!)  One of those favorite memories is making Christmas sugar cookies, decorating them with my my mom and grandmother and eventually leaving them for Santa.  It seems like my love of making things from scratch started early in life.
This post may contain affiliate links.  
A few years ago, I spent the week between Christmas and New Year’s Day in New York City.  I looked for indoor activities to occupy my time because it was so cold in the city!  Finding activities that didn’t involve shopping was a challenge, but I did enough of that in NYC as it is.

I ended up taking a cookie decorating class one afternoon with Toba Garrett at the Institute of Culinary Education. As a result of her amazing class, I bought her book. Toba taught us how to use royal icing to decorate cookies, and innovative decorating techniques. She also taught us about flavoring royal icing to match the colors because people expect things to taste like what they look like. Her class was GENIUS. If you ever find yourself in NYC, take one of her classes. She’s brilliant. It’s fun to meet people, too. (Really, all classes I’ve taken there were spectacular. I highly recommend the entire experience.)

Finding the perfect recipe for cookie cutters is tough!  There’s nothing worse than a cookie that loses its form after you have put so much time into crafting it. As a result of all my mistakes, I wanted to share my favorite cookie recipe.  This recipe was given to me during Toba’s class, and it’s never steered me wrong.  I don’t dare say it’s foolproof (nothing ever is for me!), but it is easy, simple, and perfect to use with royal icing because the cookies bake evenly.

Sharing an (almost) foolproof recipe for Christmas sugar cookies that can be used as a year-round recipe for cookie cutters! P I N I T

Christmas Sugar Cookies - Recipe for Cookie Cutters!
Author: Sara
  • 1 cup of unsalted butter (let set out for 15 minutes before using)
  • 1 cup of granulated sugar
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 teaspoon of baking powder
  • 1 teaspoon of pure vanilla extract
  • 3 cups of all purpose flour, plus extra for rolling out dough.
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. In large bowl, cream butter and sugar with mixer for 2 minutes. Stop and scrape bowl. Cream for an additional 60 seconds. Butter and sugar should not be emulsified.
  3. Beat in the egg and vanilla. Beat until well combined (15-20 seconds).
  4. Sift together baking powder and flour. Add flour mixture 1 cup at a time to the creamed butter and sugar mixture. Mix thoroughly after each addition. Dough will be stiff. Avoid over mixing.
  5. Divide dough into 2 balls. Wrap one ball in plastic wrap until ready to use. (Could be frozen for 3 months.)
  6. Divide remaining dough in two. On floured surface, roll out one of the halves to about 1/8-1/4 inch thick. Use a large offset spatula to run under the dough to prevent sticking.
  7. Cut out cookies with cookie cutters, dipping cutters into flour before each use.
  8. Place onto ungreased non-stick cookie sheet or a parchment lined half sheet pan. Bake 6-8 minutes or until edges slightly brown. Let cookies rest on cookie sheet until ready to use.

Sharing an (almost) foolproof recipe for Christmas sugar cookies that can be used as a year-round recipe for cookie cutters! P I N I T

Notes from the Kitchen – Christmas Sugar Cookies:

  • Toba taught us that we shouldn’t use Tupperware to keep cookies fresh. A cardboard box is the best way to store them!  They will stay fresh for up to 2 weeks at 70F.  Don’t use the refrigerator either.
  • Make sure you have your cookie cutters before you start. I like the Wilton brand a lot, but Sur la Table has not steered me wrong either.  Make sure you get the metal ones because they have the cleanest cuts.
  • Lastly, even if you don’t have time to decorate these cookies, they are delicious on their own.



  • Lexi’s baby shower favors! » my journey of doing - […] I baked the adorable dinosaur cookies, using my tried and true recipe for sugar cookies from Toba Garrett and Wilton’s royal icing to decorate them. I hit up the after […]ReplyCancel

  • Laura - I never heard about storing them in a cardboard box! So good to know, I will have to try that this year.ReplyCancel

  • Stephanie - They look literally perfect, my word. YUMReplyCancel

  • cara - These look so yummy! I’ve always been a fan of sugar cookies at Christmas time!ReplyCancel

  • Ashley @ The Wandering Weekenders - I love that you took a cookie decorating class when you were in NYC! That’s such a unique thing to do in the city and I’m sure that your checking account loved it over shopping too! I always love how every family has it’s own unique traditions that center around the holidays, and I can’t wait to come up with new traditions with the girls!ReplyCancel

  • Katie Elizabeth - These cookies look soooo delicious – a great way to honor your dads birthday! Thinking of you today! xoxoReplyCancel

  • Betsy - Those cookies are like perfect! OCD me loves that.ReplyCancel

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *



Rate this recipe: